Assessment Rubric for Patient Case Presentations

Student: Enter Name                          Preceptor: Scott Bolesta, PharmD, BCPS            Site: General Hospital                                               Date: Click here to enter a date.

Criteria	1	2	3	4	Score	Comments
Case Presentation (15%)	Several key pieces of subjective and objective information missing. Significant time allocated to discussion of non-pertinent information. Disorganized.	Some pertinent objective/subjective information missing and/or excessive non-pertinent information included. Audience may have difficulty following information due to organizational issues.	Most pertinent information presented and organized logically, with occasional inclusion of non-pertinent information. Minor organizational improvements needed.	All pertinent objective and subjective information is included and logically organized.	0.0	Click here to enter text.
Assessment and Plan Problem List (40%)	Difficulty arranging list in order of clinical significance.  Major improvement needed in organization, completeness and/or content. Student unprepared to discuss major disease states or associated pharmaceutical care.	Difficulty arranging list in order of clinical significance.  Moderate improvement needed in organization, completeness and/or content. Student requires additional preparation to adequately discuss disease states and associated pharmaceutical care.	Information is listed appropriately, beginning with the most clinically significant problem. Minor improvement needed in organization, completeness and/or content. Student could benefit from more preparation to understand disease states and associated pharmaceutical care.	Information is listed appropriately, beginning with the most clinically significant problem. Information is organized and complete. Student knowledgeable about disease states and associated pharmaceutical care.	0.0	Click here to enter text.
Presentation Style 35%	Confusing, lacks confidence, excessive use of notes. Presentation duration is excessively long/short. Unprepared.  No attempts made to include audience.  Distracting mannerisms	Some organizational/ preparation problems. Relied on notes. Timing over/under by 10-15 minutes. Speaking pace was rapid.  Did not engage audience to significant extent. Significant distracting mannerisms.	Organized and confident, but relied on notes. Finished within 5-10 minutes of time limitation. Speaking pace was rapid. Only minor difficulty interacting with audience.  Minor distracting mannerisms.	Organized, confident, connected to audience. Avoided distracting mannerisms. Did not rely on notes. Within time limit. Spoke at appropriate pace. Prepared to interact with audience.  Adhered to time limits.	0.0	Click here to enter text.
Questions 10%	Inappropriate response to questions; guessing at answers. Required reading of notes to answer most simple questions. Defensive.	Difficulty understanding and answering most questions.  Defensive with more challenging questions. Guessed at answers.	Difficulty efficiently / accurately responding to a few questions. No bluffing.	Efficiently articulates accurate response after thoughtful introspection of question. No Bluffing. Able to add information to question to justify response.	0.0	Click here to enter text.

Overall Score = 0.0

Final Comments: Click here to enter text.